Developing with Maven
Subject:   The Waterfall Model Applied
Date:   2003-10-24 02:32:38
From:   ianfairman
Response to: Dealing with the kitchen sink


I'm willing to be persuaded that Maven could be an improvement over raw Ant. But when I look at how Maven is put together it unsettles me. In trying to deal with that 2% I think they've overcomplicated things and forced themselves into making a lot of decisions in a short period of time which I wonder if they'll regret. I've seen this *so* many times and the results are rarely good.

Maybe XSLT isn't the answer - or maybe it's the whole answer or part of it - I don't know. But the "big bang" release of Maven leaves little room to rework design decisions without breaking things - it's the waterfall model all over again.

One final thought, which I came across this morning: Orgel's Rule which states "Evolution is cleverer than you are" ( Start with a worse-is-better solution and see where that takes you - if XP has one lesson to teach us it should be that one at least.


1 to 1 of 1
  1. The Waterfall Model Applied
    2003-10-24 04:47:03  anonymous2 [View]

1 to 1 of 1