Do not question assert { 2.0 }

by Gregory Brown

Interesting:

I asked a question on Phlip's last post about whether assert { 2.0 } was really necessary, given that it's mostly just assert_block from Test::Unit. I noticed this question disappeared from the post, because I guess it was offensive somehow.

Though it made it through the second time around and Phlip answered reasonably, he sent me a private email explaining that he had censored me because I apparently don't "get" assert { 2.0 }.

Not to pick a fight, but I personally believe that blog posts that have comments turned on should only be moderated for spam and/or abuse, which my comment was neither of. If you've got some questions about assert { 2.0 } that you'd like to see stay online without silent censorship, feel free to post them here.

This hopefully serves as a simple reminder that we should keep up with the 'open' in open source, and not silence technical questions randomly.

10 Comments

Eric
2008-02-14 14:55:54
Its also pretty interesting how you didnt link to his post...


I agree with you though, censoring is lame.

Gregory Brown
2008-02-14 15:00:01
@Eric,


Oh, hmm... I guess my tendencies to live in the technological stone age with respects to blogs is to blame for that. I assumed because it was on the same page directly below this entry, people would easily find it, but I guess feed readers (which I still don't use) don't necessarily organize posts like that.


I've added the link, thanks for pointing that out.

Glenn
2008-02-15 03:16:35
You gotta love how the same "open"(ness) of the web means the discussion can continue elsewhere like here or on sites like digg/reddit without the moderation of the author.
Peter Cooper
2008-02-15 07:46:59
More amusingly (to me, at least!) is that you're both posting on the same blog and this still happens. Perhaps that's why he took the liberty though. In any case, you're clearly the lead talent on this blog (only Daniel Berger comes close) and it seems more uncourteous than anything to censor a comment from someone with seniority on the blog you're posting on. Keep up the good work, Greg!
Gregory Brown
2008-02-15 08:26:14
@Glenn,


Yeah, certainly. Or if you're a fan of _why, hoodwink'd. I believe authors reserve a right to moderate their comment stream, but I don't like selective removal of non abusive comments. Makes it hard to tell what the story really is.


@Peter,


I've always looked up to Dan, as he's been part of the Ruby community way longer than I have. It's great to have him on the blog here. To me, it's not about seniority, but it certainly is about us posting on the same blog. I don't want folks to think all of us are following this kind of practice. Thanks for the kind words!


Ryan Platte
2008-02-18 12:43:42
Oh bother, two Rubyists I highly respect facing off with each other. Please don't assume malice.


Anyway, the comment you wrote now does appear in the comment stream, along with a lively discussion.

Gregory Brown
2008-02-18 13:10:31
@Ryan,


I've got no intentions to face off with anyone. If we didn't post to the same blog, actually, I'd find no reason to comment publicly. I just want readers to be sure that it's not universal practice here to censor based on content, and quite seriously, if people had comments about assert { 2.0 } that they could feel free to use this post to get them online.


I guess that this kind of thing isn't the most polite way of making a point, but now that I've said what I need to, I have no plans on creating further tension with Phlip because I too find his contributions interesting.

cheap mp3 player
2008-06-09 09:54:12
顾名思义就是网络cheap mp3 player,是集cheap mp3 player客户,网络cheap mp3 player媒体,网络cheap mp3 player运营商为一体cheap mp3 player展会-cheap mp3 player展会信息,展会知识,展会场馆,展览公司,cheap mp3 player制作,cheap mp3 player材料,cheap mp3 player设计全国媒体介绍cheap mp3 player报价刊例cheap mp3 player部联系电话简介分析cheap mp3 player报价媒体刊例cheap mp3 player刊例cheap mp3 player公司推荐价目表价格表cheap mp3 player.浙江恒峰cheap mp3 player公司,致力于从cheap mp3 player客户立场出发,提供有效的cheap mp3 player计划和cheap mp3 player平面设计作品.本cheap mp3 player公司服务范围有6787673@WOWGOLDS.COM
cheap mp3 player
2008-06-09 09:54:30
cheap mp3 player公司-擅长金融投资cheap mp3 player公司-法律cheap mp3 player公司-专利cheap mp3 player公司-专业领域技术cheap mp3 player公司杭州cheap mp3 player网浙江cheap mp3 player网是浙江cheap mp3 player公司杭州cheap mp3 player公司杭州户外cheap mp3 player等cheap mp3 player信息发布cheap mp3 player公司,cheap mp3 player,广州译信cheap mp3 player公司是广州一家专业cheap mp3 player公司,作为广州多语言cheap mp3 player提供商中国cheap mp3 player协会,cheap mp3 player新闻,cheap mp3 player资讯,作品,cheap mp3 player主,cheap mp3 player人才,cheap mp3 player商情6787673@WOWGOLDS.COM
cheap world of warcraft account
2008-06-09 14:13:42
提供深圳cheap world of warcraft account食住行游娱购各项资讯、各项cheap world of warcraft account产品预订、cheap world of warcraft account电子地图导游等功能。cheap world of warcraft account,济南cheap world of warcraft account网,cheap world of warcraft account网,济南cheap world of warcraft account,山东cheap world of warcraft account,美食,酒店双人cheap world of warcraft account(北京cheap world of warcraft account/上海cheap world of warcraft account/广州cheap world of warcraft account/深圳cheap world of warcraft account),cheap world of warcraft account是一家专业cheap world of warcraft account
cheap world of warcraft account公司德语cheap world of warcraft account,俄语cheap world of warcraft account,英语cheap world of warcraft account,上海cheap world of warcraft account公司,北京cheap world of warcraft account公司,cheap world of warcraft account6787673@WOWGOLDS.COM